Cherry Hill’s 15.4% Yield Looks Tempting, But a String of Dividend Cuts Tells a Cautionary Tale

3 weeks ago 15

David Beren

Mon, March 16, 2026 astatine 10:28 AM CDT 5 min read

Cherry Hill Mortgage Investment (CHMI) trades astatine $2.66 with a 15.4% annualized dividend yield, but its quarterly payout has been slashed from $0.64 successful 2017-2018 to the existent $0.10 aft a 33% chopped successful September 2025, with Q3 2025 GAAP EPS of $0.05 failing to screen the dividend wholly and net disposable for organisation remaining bladed astatine $0.11 per stock successful Q4 2025.
Cherry Hill faces headwinds from a 37.2% year-over-year gross decline, MSR portfolio shrinkage from $17.0B to $15.9B, RMBS nett involvement dispersed compression from 3.55% to 2.52%, and rising prepayment speeds that could scope 15% if owe rates fall, making dividend sustainability uncertain successful a challenging 2026 complaint environment.
A caller survey identified 1 azygous wont that doubled Americans’ status savings and moved status from dream, to reality. Read much here.

Founded successful 2012, Cherry Hill Mortgage Investment Corporation, a salient existent property concern institution (NYSE:CHMI) is flashing a 15.04% annualized dividend output astatine a banal terms of $2.66, trading astatine a meaningful discount to a publication worth of $3.44 per share. For income investors, the fig is hard to ignore, but you person to excavation into the past to cognize wherefore it deserves attention.

This output did not get from strength, arsenic Cherry Hill's dividend has been chopped repeatedly implicit caller years, and quarterly payouts that erstwhile reached $0.49 per stock successful 2017-2018 person been reduced successful stages to the existent $0.10 per quarter. The astir caller chopped came successful September 2025, erstwhile the committee slashed the payout by 33% from $0.15, pursuing a Q2 2025 4th successful which the $0.15 dividend exceeded net disposable for organisation of $0.10 per share, a wide awesome that the anterior complaint was unsustainable.

Overall, sum has been inconsistent, and successful Q3 2025, GAAP EPS of $0.05 failed to screen the $0.10 dividend. Q4 2025 offered much relief, with diluted EPS of $0.14 covering the $0.10 payout with immoderate cushion. However, net disposable for organisation came successful astatine conscionable $0.11 per share, leaving a bladed borderline supra the dividend.

Read: Data Shows One Habit Doubles American’s Savings And Boosts Retirement

Most Americans drastically underestimate however overmuch they request to discontinue and overestimate however prepared they are. But information shows that people with 1 habit person much than treble the savings of those who don’t.

An infographic titled 'The 15% Yield Trap: Is Cherry Hill's Dividend a Gift oregon a Warning?' presents information for Cherry Hill Mortgage Investment Corp. (NYSE:CHMI). The institution overview shows Stock Price $2.66 (Mar 16, 2026), Book Value Per Share $3.44 (Q4 2025), Annualized Dividend Yield 15.4% (Q4 2025), and Market Cap $97.7M. It notes 'Trading astatine a important discount to publication value.' A 'Dividend successful Freefall' timeline illustrates dividend cuts: $0.64 per 4th (2017-2018 Historical High), $0.15 per 4th (Q2 2025), and $0.10 per 4th (Q3 2025 - Current) aft a '33% Cut (Sept 2025)'. A callout states 'Q2 2025 dividend ($0.15) exceeded Earnings Available for Distribution ($0.10), signaling unsustainability.' The 'Dividend Coverage & Sustainability' conception includes 2 barroom charts: 'Q3 2025 Coverage' shows Dividend astatine $0.10 and GAAP EPS astatine $0.05, stating 'EPS FAILED to screen Dividend'. 'Q4 2025 Coverage' shows Dividend astatine $0.10 and Diluted EPS astatine $0.14, stating 'EPS covered Dividend'. Below is 'Earnings Available for Distribution (EAD): $0.11 Thin Margin'. The 'Structural Picture & Key Risks' conception details 'Portfolio & Income' with Servicing Income (Q4 2025) astatine $8.15 Million (Net), MSR Unpaid Principal Balance $15.90 Billion (Q4 2025), and Transitioned to Internal Management (Q1 2025), redeeming $858k fee. 'Risks & Headwinds' see Revenue Decline (Q4 2025 YoY) -37.2%, Aggregate Portfolio Leverage 5.4x, Derivative Volatility: Losses up to $22.74M successful a azygous quarter, MSR UPB Declining: $17.00B (Q1 2025) -> $15.90B (Q4 2025), and Rising Prepayment Speeds: RMBS CPR roseate to 8.5% from 6.1%. The 'Macro Environment & Outlook' conception reports 10-Year Treasury Yield: 4.27% (As of March 12, 2026) and RMBS Net Interest Spread Compression with Q1 2025 astatine 3.55% and Q4 2025 astatine 2.52%. Management quotes enactment 'tightening spreads' and a 'softer tone' successful owe markets, and CEO Jay Lown (Q4 2025) punctuation astir closing 2025 with different coagulated 4th by expanding publication worth and nett plus worth per share. Sources are listed astatine the bottom.

This infographic dissects Cherry Hill Mortgage Investment Corp.'s dividend show and fiscal health, highlighting concerns astir its sustainability contempt a precocious annualized yield.

Read Entire Article