When is a mental health crisis too severe for telehealth? Warning signs families shouldn't ignore

As the Lindsay Clancy execution proceedings spotlights the psychiatric attraction she received earlier the killings of her 3 children, the lawsuit has raised broader questions astir the increasing reliance connected telehealth for intelligence wellness conditions.

Nearly fractional (48.3%) of American adults with superior intelligence unwellness present person immoderate benignant of intelligence wellness attraction via telehealth, according to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA).

Clancy reportedly had 14 virtual visits with her superior psychiatrist, Dr. Jennifer Tufts, implicit a five-month period, from September 2022 done Jan. 23, 2023, according to grounds reported by the Associated Press. The last assignment was connected Jan. 23, the time earlier the killings. The 2 ne'er met successful person.

POSTPARTUM MOM LINDSAY CLANCY ON TRIAL FOR MURDER BRINGS COURT TO A HALT WITH SUDDEN BREAKDOWN

During cross-examination, Clancy’s defence attorney, Kevin Reddington, questioned Tufts astir her reliance connected virtual appointments, per AP.

Nearly fractional (48.3%) of American adults with superior intelligence unwellness present person immoderate benignant of intelligence wellness attraction via telehealth. (iStock)

"Did you ever suggest to her that 'maybe you should travel successful and spot me, alternatively than connected the computer?'" Reddington asked.

"Talking to her implicit the video didn't look similar an issue," Tufts responded. "It didn't look similar determination was thing I was missing."

CUT OFF BY YOUR ADULT CHILD? PSYCHOLOGY RESEARCHER REVEALS WHAT PARENTS SHOULD DO NEXT

Jonathan Alpert, Ph.D., a New York psychotherapist — who was not progressive successful Clancy's attraction and was speaking mostly astir telehealth alternatively than the specifics of her attraction — said virtual attraction tin enactment precise well, but that "there comes a constituent wherever a surface whitethorn not beryllium enough."

"The sicker and much unstable idiosyncratic becomes, the little comfy I'd beryllium relying exclusively connected a screen."

"If idiosyncratic is becoming suicidal, psychotic, manic, unstable oregon incapable to function, the clinician has to see whether that idiosyncratic needs to beryllium seen successful idiosyncratic oregon needs a higher level of care," Alpert, writer of "Therapy Nation: How America Got Hooked connected Therapy and Why It's Left Us More Anxious and Divided," told Fox News Digital.

"The precedence has to beryllium getting an close representation of what’s going connected and keeping the diligent safe."

Benefits and drawbacks of virtual care

Telehealth plays an important relation successful intelligence healthcare and offers galore benefits, Alpert noted.

"As a provider, I tin spot acold much radical successful a time doing virtual therapy than I could if I were doing in-office treatment," helium told Fox News Digital.

IS DRINKING EVERY DAY ALCOHOLISM? EXPERTS EXPLAIN WHERE CULTURE AND ADDICTION COLLIDE

For the patient, it eliminates the commute to the therapist's office, which could beryllium a regulation for those with engaged schedules.

"So it does let much and amended entree to attraction successful galore cases, but it does person its limitations if idiosyncratic has a terrible psychiatric disorder," Alpert said.

Lindsay Clancy sits adjacent to her defence attorney, Kevin Reddington, during her execution proceedings astatine Plymouth Superior Court connected Aug. 11, 2026. (Photo by Jonathan Wiggs/The Boston Globe via Getty Images) (Getty Images)

There are definite things astir a patient’s quality — specified arsenic hygiene, movements, agitation, intoxication oregon wide behaviour — that aren't arsenic evident connected Zoom, helium noted.

"Someone tin propulsion themselves unneurotic for an assignment and look comparatively good for 30 minutes adjacent though they're falling isolated extracurricular of it," helium said.

Signs that in-person is best

If the diligent keeps getting worse contempt predominant appointments, that's a large informing sign, according to Alpert.

"At immoderate point, the attraction program has to change, whether that means seeing the idiosyncratic successful person, getting an exigency valuation oregon moving them to a higher level of care," the adept said. (iStock)

"More appointments aren't needfully much treatment," helium told Fox News Digital. "If idiosyncratic is becoming much suicidal, paranoid, manic, disorganized, assertive oregon simply incapable to function, you can't conscionable support scheduling different video telephone and presume that's enough."

"At immoderate point, the attraction program has to change, whether that means seeing the idiosyncratic successful person, getting an exigency valuation oregon moving them to a higher level of care."

"It's helped a batch of radical get attraction who different mightiness not."

In cases wherever determination is immoderate interest astir termination oregon violence, Alpert said it’s important for the therapist to beryllium nonstop and to inquire the pursuing questions.

• Are they having thoughts of hurting themselves oregon idiosyncratic else?
• Do they person a plan?
• Do they person entree to weapons oregon different lethal means?
• Have they done thing precocious that suggests the hazard is escalating?

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR HEALTH NEWSLETTER

"If idiosyncratic says they conscionable privation to die, that's 1 happening and it's precise concerning, but if they person a plan, accidental a limb oregon pills, that brings it to the adjacent level and would surely warrant intervention, whether it's done the constabulary oregon exigency services," helium said.

If you oregon idiosyncratic you cognize is having thoughts of suicide, delight interaction the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline astatine 1-800-273-TALK (8255).

CLICK HERE FOR MORE HEALTH STORIES

It’s besides important for the therapist to cognize wherever the diligent is located during the assignment truthful that if determination is an emergency, they tin instrumentality action, Alpert advised.

"And sometimes you request accusation from household oregon different radical successful the patient's life, due to the fact that the diligent whitethorn not beryllium giving you the full picture."

A bully clinician tin place superior hazard implicit video, and astatine the aforesaid time, idiosyncratic tin miss superior hazard sitting crossed from a diligent successful an office. (iStock)

The adept besides emphasized the favoritism betwixt postpartum slump and postpartum psychosis.

"With postpartum psychosis … determination whitethorn beryllium delusions, disorganized thinking, hallucinations — and if that's what's going on, that decidedly warrants inpatient treatment."

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

Overall, Alpert said, telehealth itself is not the problem.

"It's helped a batch of radical get attraction who different mightiness not," helium said. "The bigger contented is whether the clinician is doing a thorough appraisal and whether the level of attraction inactive fits the patient's condition."

TEST YOURSELF WITH OUR LATEST LIFESTYLE QUIZ

A bully clinician tin place superior hazard implicit video, helium noted — but astatine the aforesaid time, idiosyncratic tin miss superior hazard sitting crossed from a diligent successful an office.

"The sicker and much unstable idiosyncratic becomes, the little comfy I'd beryllium relying exclusively connected a screen," helium added.